Dialogue with the office of our MNA
We wish to share an update regarding our efforts in the groundwater extraction project file in Hinchinbrooke with the office of our MNA, Carole Mallette, as well as with the relevant authorities.
Following a call from that office, we understand that assurances were conveyed indicating that the Ministry of the Environment had conducted all required analyses and that the regulatory standards in force are very strict.
While we appreciate this information, we maintain that it is difficult to confirm the completeness of the scientific evaluations without access to the precise technical documents used to support these statements.
Scientific documentation and environmental monitoring
We were informed that the permit may have been renewed in July 2025 based on analyses conducted at that time and that continuous monitoring activities are in place.
In this context, we seek clarification regarding:
- The locations and methods of monitoring
- The frequency of measurements
- The hydrological and hydrogeological parameters being observed
- The availability of data series that allow assessment of the evolution of the aquifer system
We would also like to know whether substantially updated hydrogeological studies have been conducted since the earlier work sometimes referenced, and how authorities ensure that the conceptual models remain valid in the current environmental context.
Scientific considerations in hydrogeology
A hydrogeological study cannot be considered a document with permanent validity. Its scientific relevance depends on the evolution of aquifer system conditions, environmental pressures, and the existence of long-term monitoring confirming the validity of the original assumptions.
For significant extraction projects, professional practice generally suggests periodic updates of hydrogeological assessments, often every 5 to 10 years, or sooner if significant changes occur in the environment or land use.
Even when an initial study was of high scientific quality, it reflects the environmental and methodological conditions of its time. A renewal file based primarily on older work should demonstrate, using recent data, that the conceptual model remains valid in the current context, particularly considering the potential effects of climate change.
Access to scientific information
Our group continues to request access to all scientific and administrative documents that were used to authorize or regulate the project, including full hydrogeological studies, monitoring data, pumping test results, cumulative analyses, and technical justifications underlying official decisions.
The objective of this approach is to allow independent evaluation of the information by a qualified hydrogeology expert in order to ensure rigorous understanding of the file.
We emphasize the importance of the principle of access to information in a democratic society and wish to be able to transmit these documents to an independent specialist with the necessary technical expertise.
Steps related to the CPTAQ
The formal request for review concerning the authorizations granted by the Commission de protection du territoire agricole du Québec in 2001 and 2003 has been submitted, accompanied by preliminary documents intended to illustrate the evolution of scientific knowledge and hydrogeological best practices since those authorizations were issued.
Our intention is not to challenge institutions but to encourage an informed reassessment in light of current scientific data.
Upcoming Zoom meeting
Our next Zoom meeting will take place on Wednesday, March 11, from 10:00 a.m. to 11:30 a.m. A connection link and the agenda will be sent on the Tuesday preceding the meeting.
World Water Day event
Authorization for the organization of the World Water Day event in Huntingdon has not yet been received. Follow-ups have been made with the municipal administration, and no definitive response has been provided to date. We remain awaiting confirmation in order to properly plan this awareness event.
Earth Day Forum participation
We are pleased to confirm that we will have a table at the Earth Day Forum, which will take place on April 18 at CVR.
We are grateful to have been invited to participate in this initiative and to represent our commitment to the protection of water resources as well as to environmental awareness within the community.
